I wear over-ear headphones in a quiet room, and the music sounds full and rich. Then I take them off and set them on the desk, and the music shrinks to a tiny tinny leak.
Seedance 2.0ByteDance · proprietary
Kling 3.0 OmniKuaishou · proprietary
Veo 3.1Google · proprietary
LTX-2.3Lightricks · open
Ovi 1.1character.ai · open
JavisDiT++JavisDiT · open
MagiHumanGAIR-NLP · open
Per-prompt rubric
Basic standards
Visual presence
- a person
- over-ear headphones
- a desk
Event: a person removes headphones and sets them on a desk
Audio presence
- headphones
Sound: music from headphones
Key standards
Visual physical commonsense (V-PC)
- The over-ear headphones remain headphones throughout the clip, keeping the same over-ear cup form factor before and after removal.
- The person removes the headphones from the head and sets them down on the desk.
Audio physical commonsense (A-PC)
- The music sounds full and rich while the headphones are worn on the head.
- After the headphones are placed on the desk, the same music continues at reduced bandwidth and reduced loudness as a thin tinny leak.
Cross-modal physical commonsense (AV-PC)
- The music originates from the visible headphones in the scene.
- The shift from full music to thin tinny leak occurs at or shortly after the visible removal action.